• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Sotto Le Stelle

In the bustling neighborhood of Sunnyside, NY, Sotto Le Stelle serves up delectable wood-fired pizzas, alongside a variety of appetizers, salads, and desserts. With a cozy ambiance and attentive service, this pizza spot offers a unique dining experience. Customers rave about the flavorful margarita pizza and homemade meatballs, showcasing the quality and taste of the dishes. The blend of old-school charm and modern comfort creates a warm and inviting atmosphere for guests to enjoy their meal. Sotto Le Stelle is a hidden gem for pizza enthusiasts seeking a memorable dining experience.

Sotto Le Stelle: Reviews & Ratings

Tracy S.
Tracy S.

So glad I found this place to enjoy pizza, I really love wood fire pizza and we enjoyed the margarita and their appetizer of the meatballs (definitely always order)! Love the ambiance of the place, there's a heated patio in the back too. The service was quick and friendly!

Lane M.
Lane M.

My girlfriend and I came here the other day. We both got personal pizzas and shared. The margherita and braccio di ferro were good. Service was fine. Ambiance is nice but the walking pathway through the restaurant is very narrow. All you need is one unlucky moment to bump into a server with food. The bathroom has a weird air blower (I have no idea how it worked and even if it did, I wouldn't want to use it) instead of paper towels. That was a turn-off.

Quoc L.
Quoc L.

I've been on a pizza kick and I'm astounded this place doesn't land on any listicle. Maybe that's for the better, to avoid price and foot traffic increases. We went on a Monday evening and it was so far, our best new restaurant experience of the year to date. Eurodance music pumping, chitchatter of old Italian men, delicious pizza, and the bartender chattin' it up with 2 lovely young ladies. The Earth-toned blue and gold draping the restaurant, gave it a classy and Starry Night theme. It was a mix of old school and modern comfort. The vibes were there. We opted for a single pizza between the two of us to meet our dietary goals but one can be a comfortable size for a person. Feeling a little spicy, we ordered the Angel and Devil, a pizza that actually executes the hot honey flavor very well. We've been to a few other spots that are "known" for this but they might as well be spicy ketchup. The pizza came dripping with flavor. A little watery but we found that it was a great consistency to pick up or slices and smear it on the plate. It was a hot mess in the best way possible. You can best believe we're coming back for another date night.

Ryan G.
Ryan G.

Wow my fiancé wanted to try this place out and it didn't disappoint. It's a beautiful sit down pizza restaurant that also has pasta and appetizers on the menu. You can grab a glass of wine beer or a cocktail. Thank you Matthew for the best service I can ask for. We really had a good time here. The pizza was delicious, just how I like it paper thin if that's the kind of pizza you like. The prices also are affordable for the quality of food that you get.

Kevin H.
Kevin H.

Good brick oven pizza. Small rustic spot with that brick oven burnt crust and really good dough and ingredients.

Jessica M.
Jessica M.

Great neighborhood spot for pizza/pasta dishes. They're usually pretty packed, but we always manage to score a table without waiting too long. Pretty spacious - theres a large outside dining area in the back. We came during Sunnyside Restaurant Week a while back and were hooked on their pizza's. Decided to come back to sample some other items on their menu. We ordered the Fritto Misto (fried calamari, shrimp and zucchini) to start. For mains, we had the seafood Tiella Pasta, La Carbonara Pizza, Star Pizza and Chicken Parm. The Seafood Tiella Pasta was baked with a layer of pizza dough in the oven and we dipped the dough in the pasta to soak up all the sauce. Delicious!

Dumond A.
Dumond A.

Updating my last review, as I finally had a chance to come and actually dine here (for the Sunnyside Restaurant week) rather than grab a pizza to go. I came away from the experience super satisfied and full, and would easily come here again. It's great to know there's an authentic Italian pizzeria in the neighborhood! Came with 2 friends for an early lunch and we were sat down promptly. The manager, waiters and bartenders are all Italian, which is a real good sign. Ordered the Parmigiana di Melanzane as an appetizer - and it was quite good. Followed with the Pizza Quattro Formaggi as my main and found it to be on par with any solid, good pizzeria I've been to in Italy - which is the best compliment I can give them. Made sure to get myself a good glass of red wine to go along with it and my friends got cocktails which were similarly tasty. Finished my meal with a nice gelato (tiramisu' and lemon) - but was especially blown away by their home-made dessert shot of chocolate liqueur and ice cream, which they gave to us as a thank-you for stopping by. It ended up being about $60 (tip included) - which isn't exactly super cheap, but to be fair that covered an appetizer, a (good) pizza, a glass of wine and dessert - plus I'm getting great quality here so it's a fair price. Will definitely be back.

Jan P.
Jan P.

Going out on a limb with this one: my fav restaurant in Queens!!! I cannot get over the angel and devil pizza. Order it every time. The small bites are PERFECT with a glass of wine. And the frito misto with shrimp, calamari and zucchini is light and wonderful. Cocktails are great. Affogato for dessert and a shot of lemoncello on the house. It's just what I want.

Location

Welcome to Sotto Le Stelle, a cozy and eclectic pizza spot located in Sunnyside, NY. This restaurant offers a variety of amenities such as delivery, takeout, reservations, and even vegan options for those with dietary restrictions. The ambiance of this place is described as casual, trendy, and classy, making it a perfect spot for any occasion.

When it comes to the menu, Sotto Le Stelle does not disappoint. From appetizers like the Carpaccio di Carne to salads like the Sotto le Stelle Salad, there is something for everyone to enjoy. The Nutella Calzone and Tiramisu are perfect choices for those with a sweet tooth, and the gelato options are sure to satisfy any dessert cravings.

Customer reviews rave about the delicious wood-fired pizzas, with flavors like margherita and the unique Angel and Devil pizza. The service is quick and friendly, adding to the overall dining experience.

For a memorable dining experience with delicious food and a great ambiance, Sotto Le Stelle is definitely a must-visit spot. Don't miss out on the opportunity to try their mouthwatering pizzas and delectable desserts!